Willson trial on manslaughter charge delayed until March

NORTH HERO – A state judge has agreed to postpone the upcoming involuntary manslaughter trial for Ellen Willson, 39, of St. Albans, who is charged with killing a young motorcyclist and seriously injuring his dad 16 months ago.

Willson, formerly of Alburgh, was due to go on trial in Vermont Superior Court in North Hero next month, but defense lawyer Richard McCormick asked for a delay to give him more time to prepare.

Hunter Rounds, 20, of Grand Isle was killed in a head-on crash when Willson’s southbound 2019 Chevrolet Silverado crossed the double yellow line on U.S. 2 in North Hero near Savage Point Road about 1:45 p.m. on Father’s Day 2025, Vermont State Police has said.

Rounds died at the scene.

Willson also struck a second motorcycle, injuring the victim’s father, Jason Rounds, 51, of Grand Isle, police said.

He was seriously injured in the crash and taken to the UVM Medical Center in Burlington with multiple injuries. Rounds underwent several surgeries and was eventually discharged, officials said.

During a court hearing last week, there was some dispute as to whether Grand Isle County State’s Attorney Doug
DiSabito had provided the defense some evidence on a flash drive in a timely fashion. DiSabito said turning over evidence has never been an issue in his 12 years in office and he believes he did turn over the information, but has no supportive email or documentation on providing it.

McCormick maintains he never got the material until DiSabito provided a copy before the court hearing last week.
Judge Mary Morrissey, after listening to arguments, agreed that two weeks was not enough time for the defense to review the evidence from Willson’s cellphone extraction. After reviewing upcoming schedules and possible trial dates, everybody agreed March would be the best time.

McCormick said the delay in providing the flash drive was unfair and the evidence should be excluded. But Morrissey reminded him some of the delay was due to Willson refusing to provide the passcode to her phone.

It was only after the defendant was found in contempt of court and jailed before Willson suddenly remembered the passcode for her phone. She had claimed she didn’t own the cellphone, but her comments at the crash scene and subsequent investigation revealed it was her phone, officials have said.

DiSabito has said the latest evidence showed Willson was on her cellphone and taking pictures just before the crash.

The jury selection is now planned for March 18 with the projected week-long trial starting March 22.

McCormick made another unsuccessful motion to move the high-profile case out of Grand Isle County because he believed it would be difficult to find a neutral jury. An earlier request was rejected by another judge.

Morrissey said she reviewed the results of a questionnaire created by the lawyers and court and sent to potential jurors. She said based on their answers she believed there were sufficient people that could be fair. Morrissey said she believed she identified 52 people that said they knew nothing or little about the fatal crash and could be fair.

DiSabito agreed, noting he found 56 people were acceptable to the state for consideration.

McCormick said he had cut his list to 24 people that he thought would be neutral.

The judge said 52 could be enough to find a jury and she would be willing to give it a try.

However, in the end, with the delay granted by Morrissey, she said a new jury panel will be summoned by the time the trial gets underway in March. She offered the lawyers a chance to propose tweaks to the questionnaire when it goes out to a new group of Grand Isle County residents.

Morrissey did say the new panel of prospective jurors will be summoned for March, and they would be quizzed about what they know about the case and if they had made up their mind.

The veteran judge said she would hold another pre-trial hearing Nov. 19 to make sure things kept moving forward.
DiSabito has said McCormick has repeatedly missed court-imposed deadlines since the case began.

Willson has pleaded not guilty to several charges, including involuntary manslaughter and two counts of gross negligent operation: one with death resulting and one with serious bodily injury, all from the June 15, 2025, crash.

The lawyers have said they were concerned that some potential jurors might not show. DiSabito noted about half the people were missing from the last jury draw day in North Hero in July.

Potential jurors failing to appear when ordered face possible contempt of court proceedings and a civil fine of $200.

When potential jurors failed to show for the high-profile assault trial of Franklin County Sheriff John Grismore, which was moved to North Hero, a judge ordered Grand Isle County Sheriff Ray Allen to go out onto U.S. 2 by the courthouse and stop motorists to locate potential jurors. It helped fill out the jury.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *