Isle La Motte planners finalize highway study, continue town hall research

ISLE LA MOTTE – Local planners on Isle La Motte are expected to finalize a report over the coming weeks exploring the costs of establishing a local highway department, a charge initially brought to the planning commission shortly after Town Meeting Day.

The pending report comes as Isle La Motte planners continue their research into the costs of maintaining or demolishing Isle La Motte’s former municipal building on Main Street.

According to town officials, the planning commission was expected to present a completed report to Isle La Motte’s selectboard during a meeting focused on local highway projects in November. The report, as of early October, had already extended to more than 100 pages that planners hoped to simplify with a more easily digested executive summary.

“It started out small,” the planning commission’s chairperson, Carmine Centrella, told members of Isle La Motte’s selectboard earlier this month. “It was a lot of work, but we wanted to make sure that we tried to anticipate as many questions as possible.”

The commission has yet to share its report publicly. According to meeting minutes, however, the report is expected to consider advantages and disadvantages for certain staffing and contracting arrangements, as well as information about municipal highway departments from nearby communities like North Hero.

The planning commission in Isle La Motte was initially charged with studying the possible development and staffing of a local highway department after Town Meeting Day in March.

Unlike other communities in the Champlain Islands, Isle La Motte does not staff a highway department and instead employs a part-time road commissioner to oversee local road-related projects. Much of the maintenance for Isle La Motte’s public highways is handled by construction companies and contractors.

Road maintenance has featured prominently in Isle La Motte politics in recent years as officials navigated what some have described as a backlog in local highway projects. Town officials have already identified road maintenance as a likely priority for Isle La Motte’s next municipal budget.

While Isle La Motte’s selectboard has yet to publicly discuss the planning commission’s findings with any detail, early impressions shared by selectboard members in October were largely positive.

“It’s an impressive body of work,” the selectboard’s chairperson Cary Sandvig said. “It is very thorough.”

“This is amazing and will be truly helpful,” selectperson Mary Catherine Graziano agreed. “I think we have some really good bones to build off of for planning.”

Old town hall work remains ongoing

While the planning commission was close to finishing its report on the costs associated with developing a local highway department, Centrella said the commission’s study exploring the costs of maintaining or demolishing Isle La Motte’s former municipal hall was still ongoing.

After some public discussion about the meeting hall during the summer, as well as a thinly attended open house meant to highlight maintenance issues with the former municipal building, Isle La Motte officials tasked the planning commission with mapping the possible costs for the municipal building’s preservation and demolition.

The commission’s work was meant to also build on a recent architectural study that suggested that the building would need substantial renovations, including a new foundation, before it could be reopened for public use. That study had placed the meeting hall’s likely renovation costs at around $1.2 million.

Early results from a townwide survey circulated by Isle La Motte’s planning commission had apparently found respondents largely uninterested in maintaining the historic building, according to Centrella.

“The majority wants, it seems, for the town to rid itself [of the building], and that’s my word, whether they sell it, donate it or demolish it,” Centrella told officials in early October. “You get the flavor from some of the responses that we’ve been revisiting this enough.”

According to Centrella, it was possible those results could change. At the time of Centrella’s report to the selectboard, there was still time for Isle La Motte residents to respond to the survey. Following a social media push by Isle La Motte officials, the survey was ultimately closed to new responses early last week.

The commission’s work had also identified some grants that could possibly support the municipal hall’s eventual restoration, with Centrella singling out in particular the U.S. National Park Service’s Paul Bruhn Historic Revitalization Grants Program tapped by other Vermont communities, including South Hero, to support local building restorations.

During a brief discussion about the ongoing study, Isle La Motte officials ultimately discouraged their local planning commission from prioritizing renovations that could cost the town money or redirect grant funding from projects focused on improving Isle La Motte’s current municipal offices in the former Isle La Motte Elementary School.

“The people don’t want us to spend taxpayer money on this building, right?” selectperson Joseph Deller said. “I don’t think it is worth our time to continue to put options that require taxpayer money in front of people when they’ve loudly said to stop doing that.”

An option that Deller did seem to support, however, was allowing a hypothetical group of community members interested in preserving the municipal hall to take over the building, provided that they had “some kind of business plan” proving their renovation plans were viable.

According to Centrella, the commission considered hosting a public meeting over the coming months to discuss the former municipal building. Officials suggested having the selectboard lead that meeting, as decisions about the former town hall would ultimately fall to the board.

“If you do have a public meeting, it shouldn’t just be you guys in the firing line,” Graziano said. “It should be an actual selectboard meeting, because it’s our job to be in the firing line.”

The Main Street municipal hall has largely remained vacant after Isle La Motte’s government relocated to the former Isle La Motte Elementary School on School Street in 2021. At the time, town officials cited continued maintenance issues and concerns about available space when justifying their move from their longtime municipal building.

According to the Vermont State Register of Historic Places, Isle La Motte’s former municipal office dated back to the early 1900s and had briefly housed a classroom on its second floor.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *